Surviving China’s Uighur camps

रोजी प्रकाशित केले 10 मे, 2019
Subscribe to France 24 now:
f24.my/youtubeEN
FRANCE 24 live news stream: all the latest news 24/7
f24.my/YTliveEN
In China’s northwestern Xinjiang region, more than one million ethnic Uighurs are believed to be held in internment camps. The authorities call them "re-education through labour camps", but victims say the reality is forced indoctrination for Uighurs held in alarming conditions. From China to Canada, via Turkey and France, our reporters Angélique Forget and Antoine Védeilhé investigated the plight of the Uighurs and gathered rare testimony. This is their exclusive report.
Visit our website:
www.france24.com
Subscribe to our MRlevel channel:
f24.my/youtubeEN
Like us on Facebook:
FRANCE24.English
Follow us on Twitter:
France24_en

टिप्पण्या

  • This also CNN,BBC,a french edition. MSM.

  • Allah Almighty have mercy upon them

  • May Allah s.v.a protect all Muslims all over the world Ameen

  • Bad intentions

  • AllahuAkbar

  • Unbelievable how many people believe this to be true. Very nice acting, western media. Half my family is from Xingjiang and this is unheard of. Western countries just make up shit because they want to suppress China, like how they always have to stick their stinky nose into other nation's affairs.

  • fake fake fake

  • The world should unite to suppress the communist china, evil is on the loose

  • This is a good technic of cutting & pasting of the video, the main thing is the speaker who tell thestory behind the scene, it can be any asia country that they want point at, please be smart don't be fool the video. you should come up with some questions whether this is real or.... who knows

  • Chinas attempt to convince the world that it is a modern 1st world country has failed miserably. The truth is it is just another dictatorship that daily terrorises anyone and any group of people who don't fit their model of a Chinese model citizen i.e., Chinese clone/robot, someone who has their individuality removed and becomes an exact replica of the next person, someone who acts without questioning, a clone who works only for the Chinese state, making profits for the Chinese elites, a type of modern slavery. The rest of the world has more or less turned their backs on people like the Uighurs, they value their cheap Chinese goods more than the lives of these people, the Chinese dictatorship have always known this, it allows them to proceed with their genocidal plans without shame, they will wipe these peoples individuality from the face of the earth without consequences from the rest of the world. The west obviously has forgotten the lessons of the Holocaust and is now in the midst of allowing a second Holocaust to take place right under their noses, all so that they can keep buying cheap Chinese goods. Governments in the West talk about how the Chinese disregard human rights, they never act to end the torture of these people, appeasement of Hitler didn't work why would appeasement of Xi Jinping work any differently. People need to act and not wait on their governments as they will never act. Seek out charities and organisations that are actively working to help people like the Uighur.

  • Heartbreaking. Sending love

  • liars is mean to lie. Believers is mean to believe. No need to clarify anything for Chinese government. We all know you did good job to manage your country, they are just been jealous. Your people support you. That's enough. If they want to bring another war, then bring it on. They gonna bury themself one day by their lies one fires.

  • Be patient to survival of life n pray more is the best solution

  • What must be learnt from this from the defeat of NATO in Afghanistan and the Chinese success in Uighuristan? What lessons must be drawn for the fight against islamist terrorism? Sure it is not possible to copy the Chinese methods for European states. But it is pos-sible to care for the education of muslim youth in Europe! Also to look into the sermons held in European mosques. The power of Saudi petrodollars must be broken, by interdicting the money donations transferred to European mosques. To interdict the formation of imams outside of Europe. The minds of muslims must be conquered! And this not by military means. Military means have failed in this task in Afghanistan. This is what must be learnt from the Chinese victory in Xinjiang/Uighuristan. * The reformist university professor for Islam and international relations Prof. Bassam Tibi, of Syrian origin, writes that if there is no success in replacing conservative Sharia-orientated Islam in Europe by a sharia-free reform-Islam, the result will be the clash of civilisations in Europe. Professor Tibi can be found here on MRlevel, but not speaking English language (which knows how to speak). If not, the fight against terrorism will be lost also in Europe, and the solution of Michel Houllebecq will be the only one remaining: To split Europe into a Eu-ropean part and an Islamic/Islamist part.

  • this is financially aided by anti-China organizations, well edited just for you to believe , shame!

  • If our military don’t step us and save our country.. these Democrats are going to put us in this kind of mess. They letting the illegals invade our country..

  • Its sad how me and my friends were sharing this info on fb 7years ago and now the world has became fully aware of whats going on behind closed doors let alone one human life too many gone...

  • The lack of humanity and significant ignorance included on many of these comments are appalling...

  • I got laugh when going through this video. No interest in finishing all. Shame of France 24. A fake news channel. Bye!

  • 动态网自由门 天安門 天安门 法輪功 李洪志 Free Tibet 六四天安門事件 The Tiananmen Square protests of 1989 天安門大屠殺 The Tiananmen Square Massacre 反右派鬥爭 The Anti-Rightist Struggle 大躍進政策 The Great Leap Forward 文化大革命 The Great Proletarian Cultural Revolution 人權 Human Rights 民運 Democratization 自由 Freedom 獨立 Independence 多黨制 Multi-party system 台灣 臺灣 Taiwan Formosa 中華民國 Republic of China 西藏 土伯特 唐古特 Tibet 達賴喇嘛 Dalai Lama 法輪功 Falun Dafa 新疆維吾爾自治區 The Xinjiang Uyghur Autonomous Region 諾貝爾和平獎 Nobel Peace Prize 劉暁波 Liu Xiaobo 民主 言論 思想 反共 反革命 抗議 運動 騷亂 暴亂 騷擾 擾亂 抗暴 平反 維權 示威游行 李洪志 法輪大法 大法弟子 強制斷種 強制堕胎 民族淨化 人體實驗 肅清 胡耀邦 趙紫陽 魏京生 王丹 還政於民 和平演變 激流中國 北京之春 大紀元時報 九評論共産黨 獨裁 專制 壓制 統一 監視 鎮壓 迫害 侵略 掠奪 破壞 拷問 屠殺 活摘器官 誘拐 買賣人口 遊進 走私 毒品 賣淫 春畫 賭博 六合彩 天安門 天安门 法輪功 李洪志 Winnie the Pooh 劉曉波动态网自由门

  • If Xinjiang is left to the ultras, then there will another failed state.

  • Weapons of Mass Destruction, Iraq army killing babies in hospitals now this bs from USA

  • mrlevel.info/two/rZ6sopypgHuWlJs/vhi-i

  • @9:03 can you pls share the coordinates so I can see for myself

  • lol france bans muslims head covering and they care about uyghur muslims LOLOLOL!!

  • More 70 countries support China at UN General Assembly regarding Xinjiang. Paid to lie.

  • At the end of the video, I see one of the Uighurs promoting independence and their own country, an area size of France inside China. The purpose of this program seems to want this. China won't even give up little Macao or Hong Kong. This program is like trying to foment a revolution or riot. I can't see how China will allow that. Sounds like a Western TV program aiming to create more revolution and violence in another country. No foreign country will allow either.

  • China invites foreign journalists into Xin Jiang to see for themselves the facts regarding the Uighur Chinese. Even without any China invitation, foreign journalists are free to visit Xin Jiang - all without government supervision. But Western corporate media refuse to visit Xin Jiang as their lies and secret agenda against China must not be exposed.

  • I am curious can people make video at the police station i UK. I should try some days😄

  • Wonderful editing and soundtrack.

  • All the evidence we have for "genocide" is the narrative of some people, even in their words they didn't mention killing, not to mention the pictures only showed some people gathering, it could be a real prison. I am not brainwashed. I know there's lack of freedom of speech to some extent in China, and corruption and other stuff. But I think we are a lot better than this. Uyghurs and other minorities got extra points in the exam to enter universities compared to Han Chinese, a bit like US favoring native americans in terms of eduction and job opportunities. Why France24 doesn't want to cover any of that in their report? It is so easy to find proof. I think France24 only wants to publish what they want to show to the audience. I suggest France24 starts scrutinizing what French government did in Rwanda's genocide first(politically and economically supporting the government who incited the genocide) and go to Xinjiang yourself to see the truth.

    • @Crewmate I think the history will tell the truth eventually my dear. If genocide does happen, I don´t think we can hide it. If you search a bit more on the figures of population census, you will find Uygurs population is growing all these years. If you don´t believe, then just go to see it for yourself. Here is another alternative. In Paris, there are quite a lot of Uyghur restaurants. You can go and ask them what really happens back in their hometown, a lot better than watching these videos. And they have a more objective and neutral opinion about China. Have you found any evidence other than media´s narrative? There are other voices too. For example, Maxime Vivas, a French writer, just to have another perspective wouldn´t hurt.

    • @Crewmate ok fair enough have a nice day

    • @Crewmate but here’s the thing, this matter is not an matter of opinion. There either is genocide or there isn’t. Only one right answer, no opinion.

    • @Crewmate yup that’s the reason I watched this to see if I can find anything new. But this is why the proof in this video is a little watery. The girl who says she’s in a camp for a year singing the song couldn’t get the tune or words right. I think you would know how the song goes if you were made to sing it for a year. The guy who said their brother was learning about the communist party actually said “yi shu” which means art, this news source translated into communist. All the other things can’t say anything except the fact that the buildings exist. Not that I don’t respect it it’s just that all the proof I’ve looked at is a little suspicious.

    • @Crewmate Any evidence? Not that those places exist but proof of abuse and mistreatment. I looked into some but they all seemed to be debunked.

  • what a great chinese man, what ethnicity is he?

  • sb 250

  • Racist ETIM sympathizers, With an axe to grind against the majority Han chinese.

  • You should make a separate channel just for documentaries. Just as DW, otherwise we're not going to subscribe, as we're not interested in short videos, but 15+ minutes documentaries are very good

  • Let’s see what will happen ten years later in Xinjiang. Your news will be a joke when people look back at your news again ten years later. It is true China has government controlled medias, but your biased news are much worse.

  • This woman does even know how to speak Chinese well. I would say, she is a good actress to make people believe some "truths" and "justices"

  • China has an Islamic terrorist problem and is trying to solve it in a Chinese way by having re-education camps for some Uyghurs, the majority are free and there are lots of mosques open for worship. It’s China way to avoid a 9/11, Iraq/afghan wars. Talking about genocides, the whole Middle East is a genocide hell, largely caused by American wars. Accusing China of genocide is America taking the fight into China to stop her rise. Biden said he’ll not allow China to overtake USA as if permission is required. China can built a 1000 bed hospital in 10 days, a sky scrapper in 59 days, has 20,000km of high speed rails of which USA have none. China has said they will not invade anyone. Surely it’s better to work with China for world peace. There may be tension in the Taiwan strait but no war, and there won’t be if the USA stay calm about it.

  • That's very strange....The Uighur in Xinjiang can speak Mandarin, and they don't speak the Chinese language. They can even speak English. I am wondering if they are even Uighurs.

  • 2020年全疆接待遊客1.58億人次 2019年,新疆接待游客历史性突破2亿人次、实现旅游收入超3400亿元人民币,两项数据增幅均超40%。 2018年新疆全年旅遊人數突破1.5億人次,增長率超過40%。 go check with your own eyes.....

  • The world only terrorist - the American Politics!

  • Please please speak more about muslim uighurs and how chinna do for them...... Please please.....

  • Why are the other countries of the world allowing this? This is a human rights violation!

    • You know, a year ago I thought this was real until know I look back at it and realize how stupid this was.

    • because they know this is fake news. I am Chinese. I know minority have many privileges. Most of university have halal food restaurant . Around my living area there are some restaurants owned by Uyghurs . how do west countries treat with terrorist? just free them?

  • CHINALIZATION! New Colonial strategy.

  • Someone is lying. But who?

  • Western medias always like to make up this kind of fake news about China to fool western people, so sad!!!

  • I’ve been watching Numuves, CTGN, Living in China, Cyrus Jansenn and many more. After a year, I’m seeing this video with different eyes. France banned Muslim women from wearing Hijab in higher education places, Halal food and many oppressive acts on muslims, you’re telling me they care about muslims in China... hmmmmm

    • This is what western fake media doing so hard since few years trying to accuse China about human rights with bais prejudice. I laughted so hard how video were invented with BBC filtering, 1 or 2 actors even don't know how to sing a song or how to speak chinese. Stupid background music, few police station, CCTV camera all over the word. With big title of human chinese human rights, Then hit up to 70M views. Big Bais Channel, shame on you.

    • Same

    • Same! That is exactly what I’m like. A year ago I thought this was real!

  • It's a ridiculous the woman even did not know how to sing the song properly if she has been requested to sing the song every day. Obviously fake news!

  • I am wondering how many people in the world have been misled by this specific fake news!!! US is really good at playing such dirty games to incite riots in other countries, then take advantage of their internal disorders. Disgusting fake news!!!

    • This is a French public news tv.

  • She sings badly

  • mrlevel.info/two/e52chIGNhpPWeqM/vhi-i

  • Your tune is not standard.

  • Wiki: From the 20th century on, Uyghur separatists and their supporters used East Turkestan (or Uyghurstan) as an appellation for the whole of Xinjiang or for a future independent state in present-day Xinjiang Uyghur Autonomous Region (presumably with Ürümqi as its capital)

  • Bs propaganda

  • Her singing sold her out, her singing doesn’t sounds like been kept in a camp singing those songs every day for a year and half! Those people will say anything That West would like to listen and believe to get their refugee status!

    • Yup. Even tone deaf person could sing a song if they were forced to listen it n sung it countless time.

  • 54 countries mostly Muslim Countries Supported China in UN against the fake Accusation by USA and it’s allies.

  • This is a shame, peace to all humans 💔💔

    • Yup. Such blantant lies while thinking all the viewers are stupid. Such a shame to present day journalism.

  • Xinjiang is the only place on earth with Prisons. Therefore, the West are very astonished

  • Long live CCP

  • Do you have a better alternative??????, Or like some countries, wage WAR against middle East countries, mess up their country, kill innocent civilian while killing your so called enemies, and why all the sudden, the west CARE so much about Muslims..... VERY VERY STRANGE

  • The Black Lives Matter movement & Anti-Asian situation had not yet been resolved, yet they are pointing fingers at other nations. How low can one get? LOL.

  • Talking about rubbish!

  • See this woman predicted the Xinjiang issues in 2015 ! This is an Eyeopener 👍 . Is she a fortune teller ? @

    • Nope. Its just a narrative they are building up.

  • After world war 2 everyone said "Never Again". But, Why everyone is silent today. May Allah protect Chinese Muslims ❤️

    • The huis are fine tho...

  • The West should not try to stir things up in Xingjiang. They know that the more they try to infiltrate, the more the Chinese government will respond. Who really is hurting the Uighur? This game between states is not at all new. I don't know why some people have no sense as to why they should not repeat history.

  • My post about Brown university study on America Wars keeps being deleted, what are you afraid of? Truth?

  • America genocide, auto delete test.

  • based on studies Brown University ,In so called US's wars on terror in 85 countries which is accompanied by violations of human rights and civil liberties, in the US and abroad, AT LEAST 800,000 people were killed, Including 335,000 civilians, among these, just in one military action when US force targeted a religion school, yes, a school, 12 childern were killed. And these are not including 37 million refugees caused by these wars and not including MANY TIMES MORE have died indirectly in these wars, due to malnutrition, damaged infrastructure, and environmental degradation. Why NO one care about that? And why western media never report that?

  • 15:33 the guy says his brother is learning "Yi Shu" (art) but the translation says "the Communist Party". Did I hear it wrong?

    • Thus the voice over instead of subtitle.

    • You are right, he said “yi shu (art)” not “gong Chan dang” CCP, purposely misleading translation

  • sad

  • Funny that one society gets to choose who is right and who is wrong in their thinking. Much like the new propaganda world order spreading in our nation right now.

    • 15:33 its yi shu, not gong chang dang. See how they shape your right n wrong?

  • Western figh teroriseme its goods China figh teroriseme ist wrong Are you kidding me? Stop propoganda xinjiang always part of china no one can take it

  • If Western companies don't approve of Uighur working conditions why don't you simply pay them more? All Chinese have the same working conditions as Uighurs, so that European and Americans can enjoy a better life.

  • Sad,,Sad,,,Sad,,,,

  • how could she survive and leave the camp singing like this

    • @modo again, those channels I recommend were only for you to see what a normal person in China would look like. There are many more sources that I have but I can’t post them hence the reason why I said do your own research. The reason why you can’t use Laowai86 is bc he no longer lives in China and most of his info is misleading like when he told everyone how he escaped China, there were so many things wrong with that. Even tho they are MRlevel videos, they still have info and are actually logical especially Cyrus, and Daniel. There is another channel called Bay Area415, he has a video called “ American debunks all major western propaganda against Uyghur and China.” This is a great video and it also proves how BBC and many other media lies about them. Western media is used bc most propaganda is coming from them. There are definitely countries who also report bad on China but main ones are those in the west.

    • @Macy Y I will watch the channels you recommended and have already watched some of them before you mentioned it. The main concern I have with them though, especially for the pro-CCP MRlevelrs who live in China, is their ability to speak openly and honestly about the government, especially if it's not positive. Can they freely express themselves without reprisal if they say something negative about the CCP? If not, doesn't that then damage the credibility of what they're saying or showing? Another issue is the fact that these people are MRlevelrs but not real journalists. I wouldn't use channels like theirs to conclude China isn't committing genocide any more than I would use channels like laowhy86 or serpentza to conclude China IS committing genocide. A final issue I'll mention is a lot of these channels make the accusation of a so-called "Western media narrative" or "fake allegations of the West" or "Western lies about China." I think these phrases can be misleading because a lot of what I've learned recently about China has come from the media of other Asian countries, not the West. But accusing the West of fabricating all bad news about China can be used to simply dismiss it without judging the merits of the claims. Also when the phrase "Western media lies" is used, it implies other countries, when speaking out against what China is doing to them, don't have their own voice but are merely puppets of the West. It denies them their own voice, just like they deny the voice of Taiwan and Hong Kong and the Uyghurs. Edit: I'll will give it a watch though, starting with Cyrus Janssen "How Western Media Shapes Our Perception of China." Maybe he will address my questions.

    • @Macy Y I wasn't trying to miss your point about the U.N. I get it, they don't recognize Taiwan as a country. But de facto, Tawain is an independent country with different laws from China, different rulers, different currency, different citizenship, even if they don't have a seat at the U.N. Most of the countries that officially recognize the PRC and the CCP as the legitimate Chinese government also maintain diplomatic relations with Taiwan, which isn't something countries normally do for a territory or province of another country. In fact, Taiwan's passport has more power (visa free or visa on arrival travel) than the Chinese one, and that takes recognition and cooperation from other nations, which they do have. But that isn't the main point, my point, which you kinda made for me with the hypothetical scenario of China invading Taiwan is that, unlike the U.K., China doesn't respect the will of the people inhabiting the place they call its territory (even though as far as I know, the CCP has never ruled Taiwan). On top of that, they aren't respecting their motto of "one country, two systems" in Hong Kong. And, they are aggressive towards neighboring countries and don't respect their sovereignty either.

    • @modo and on the Hong Kong bit. I have tried to post links to sources but they get deleted. You can again do some research and see why the central government would crack down on Hong Kong and how some people are actually pro China. I recommend MRlevel over a search bc generally a video is easier to follow and more details.

    • @modo I’m talking uk as a whole not just Republic of Ireland. And like I explained no matter if CCP lets them have a choice or not, Taiwan is not recognized by the UN as an independent country. They have lost to the PRC and that’s period. Technically speaking they are still in a time of war except they are not fighting PRC could invade each other any time to claim or expand its borders and it would not count as the invading a country bc Taiwan is not recognized by the UN as an independent country. Even though this action will be wrong but that’s the sad truth. Plus, I was going to say do some research on fake allegations made by the west and how people have numerous times debunked it. You’ve completely missed the point 😑

  • We all should love our own country.Thats the china wants.

    • Isnt it mandatory? I mean...if you dont love the country you are born to, leave.

  • I have not been to Xinjiang but been to Guangzhou many times, recommend my Malay muslim friends to go there for a family trip. They visited Mosque and eat halal food over there, no issue of perform daily prayers. They comment to me they never realise how muslim friendly China is.

  • très bizarre les commentaires se sont démultipliés depuis 6 jours

  • People watching such kind of video would believe that Xinjiang and China is the most scaring place in the world and people there are dying and need the saving from outside to get freedom. Really speechless,to see is to believe,I do suggest everyone compare the report on one topic from more diversified sources and try to stay objective as much as possible.I don't want to quarrel and debate, wish you happy in your world.

  • read about the comments under this video. it seems a lot of people had believed what the video says, just like they believed there is WMD in Iraq. hopeless. I'm afraid the conflict between west and east will last for a long time :)

    • @Jeffrey Phua Yeah, hes grasping straws already. I mean...the so called internment camp is recent. China only started clamping down only after 2009 urumqi riot. A 50-ish woman would be 40-ish if she were captured. Also, apparently he never heard of google earth. Oh well. Haters always gonna hate.

    • @Eleeth Tahgra Shall we just stop responding to him? What do you think? He's desperately craving for attention.

    • @Eleeth Tahgra Forced assimilation could be involved in genocide. I don't know why you think they're mutually exclusive. Your questions really don't make sense, she was forcibly sterilized years back when she was younger. If they dump a bunch of people in the desert the world would know what's going on.

    • @Jeffrey Phua I doubt he would concede. Too brainwashed to even realize the plot holes thats beeing fed to his brain.

    • @Eleeth Tahgra You and I have been having fun poking holes in his arguments yet he feels no shame. It boggles the mind how much humiliation he will go through before he finally concedes.

  • US needs re-education camps to house, feed and train thousands and thousands of homeless and sick people living on the streets across the US. Homeless on the streets living on filth on tents where rats roamed and human defecation makes the odor almost unbearable to humans senses.

  • Infidel china is doing a right thing, our people can grow in to one community in the prison, and share experiences of terrorism, how mohmad salwasallam did when he attacked other villages, allahoo has lost interest for he is in hell now, mohmad is in hell now for faking ID of a true prophet and raping and killing lot of men..

  • should a series. surving holocausts remind europe about human rights set a good example for the world

  • how much the paid? another 1M!

  • I just don't understand why those western media fake the news and attack xinjiang people, what they are going to do is not really care whether it is true or not, just stop using Chinese products, so confused, seems like they are doing nothing, just try to destroy xinjiang people!

  • Satellite image of god-knows-what has sudd6 becomes a concentration camp.

  • Fake Video and I don't give it a shit! Fake news

  • Loooool. Soooo, how did you guys “escape” the evil China ? Someone sent you a private plane from Europe ?

  • sad to look at this, i can hear all of u my brothers and sisters of freedom and dignity.

  • If teaching of Chinese to Uyguar is not right, why American teaching English to non white?

    • @Daniel Pang why do you china-bots always tell people to "come to china" lol

    • @Jeffrey Phua What does the Iraq war and WMD have to do with anything? What does Western media even have to do with anything?

    • @Jeffrey Phua You claimed amnesty was controlled by the US government and media, this is slander, you have 0 proof. The organizations differ on the numbers but all the organizations say it's happening. Holy crap you're dumb.

    • @Stare Kotlety I don't know where you learn your English from. It cannot be slander if it's true. There are human rights organisations that say the number of those detained is one million. Others say it's three million. They cannot even get the number straight yet they expect others to believe them? Only a fool like you would believe such nonsense. The population of the Uyghurs has doubled in the last 40 years. If there is Indeed genocide why build camps instead of slaughtering and cremating them on the spot. Much cheaper and cleaner, don't you think? You don't even dare acknowledge that the west lied about the Iraq war. You have no credibility left. Just stop humiliating yourself if there's any more shame left in you.

    • @Jeffrey Phua Those organizations didn't say anything about WMD and criticized the US for Iraq, you're just flat out lying now. The genocide is real.

  • Uyguars wording are printed on RMB, 25000 mosque are in Xinjiang. If there are really a genocide how come there are no footage of the killing? Current almost all people have mobile phone any one can have the footage taken.

    • @Stare Kotlety simple example: in this video the guy said “yi shu” when he was talking about what his family members were learning which means arts in Chinese but this media decided to translate it into “communist party”

    • @Stare Kotlety you are speaking from a point of assumption. There are many people who go in there and learn and report no abuse on them or anyone within the centers. Why are you only believing those who claim they have been abuse but not those who claim they haven’t? I looked at both and researched to find out that a lot of the testimonies agains China were false and well proven to be. There are so many Uyghurs who have social media accounts where they share clothing, dances, songs, and culture freely inside of China. The Uyghur population has grown one fold and faster than Han Chinese is enough to prove whether there is genocide or not. Uyghurs and all other minorities inside China enjoy extra points on GaoKao, special foods in cafeterias, and many other benefits. In the province of Xinjiang alone there is more mosques than the entire United States and you are saying they are being genocide? Do you know how many celebrities and public figures have a Uyghur identity and publicly display it? You have never been to China, you have never experienced anything, all the things you know about China is from politicians and media that is extremely bias. I have never been in a camp so I don’t have the qualifications to tell you 100% that there is no genocide. But evidence of genocide in Xinjiang have all been debunked while many Uyghurs are speaking out about what their life is actually like. Strong evidence also proves western media to be fabricating lies or purposely mistranslating information and using disgusting editing skills and filters. I once believe what the west told me until I looked into it and realized how fake everything was. If you have proof tell me if you don’t then don’t talk.

    • @Macy Y The Chinese government do put them there to be subject to genocide and abuse. Some are forced to assimilate, others are killed, this is considered genocide.

    • @Stare Kotlety you know what, this is what I’m trying to say: re-education centers do exist but they do not put Uyghurs in there to be abused or genocide nor do they do what western media claims to be happening. There are plenty of people who received better opportunities after learning a skill in the center and got a better life who shared their experience. Why doesn’t anyone believe them?

    • @Stare Kotlety you also know what, allegations have been debunked. If you have proof you can tell me and I will explain to you why it has hundreds of holes in them. Those human rights organizations follows what mainstream media says and if you look at it most reports media reports comes from a study by Adrien Zenz, a German who does not speak Chinese nor has ever been to China. He makes statistics when he has no study in making statistics. I have more than once tried to post links with info but they all get deleted or hidden.

  • Other Muslim countries are silent, the Chinese trolls are bombarding videos like this with tons of whataboutism and dislikes, and refusing to take the blame for the Muslim genocide in Xinijang. It's disturbing how this is occurring while the Uyghurs are still suffering.

    • @Nice try CN Do you think that all those Uyghurs leaving are all CIA trolls? Since you claim they're all lying.

    • @Nice try CN Yes, I am James Bond, ever since lockdown they forced me to stay inside and argue with wumaos and brainwashed Chinese ultranationalists on online comment boards.

    • @Stare Kotlety CIA troll?

    • @Macy Y Probably because you're linking propaganda.

    • @Stare Kotlety MRlevel deletes my comments when I try to give proof of western lies

  • I wonder if a group of people from another country advocate for state independence what the government would do.

    • @mengjiao zhang The Chinese government shouldn't remain in power over China, they have killed many people in their attempt to stay in power. The government will eventually be overthrown but before that happens Xi and his clowns will kill a lot more people.

    • @mengjiao zhang Many people were interviewed and said similar, there have been human rights organizations sounding the alarm for close to a decade now.

    • @Stare Kotlety I don’t necessarily agree with what the current government has done in Hong Kong, and the education camp doesn’t seem to be very persuasive. It’s better to enhance their awareness of citizenship while acknowledge what the people believe in. However I can tell the challenges/threats that China may face. What if there are false prophets telling people to overturn the government and do extreme actions? And they also have weapon supplies? I understand why the government put a stable Xinjiang society a priority, including people acknowledging the CPC, not diversity at the moment. China needs Xinjiang for the belt and road initiative which can gain China especially the less developed west region more fortune. When China becomes real strong, I believe the government will be more tolerant to different voices.

    • @Stare Kotlety Why are you so certain that there is a genocide? Have you ever questioned if the information you’ve received tells the whole story? And do you know the background of people whom the BBC interviewed? Can they represent the uyghurs?

    • @Eleeth Tahgra 1. People are allowed to say that Crimea should be independent. 2. They are allowed to talking about declaring independence. 100% legal 3. That's not true. Especially if it's slow like China's genocide.

  • damnit I really smell something fishy by watching how the policemen stopped the reporters from visiting the camps. I mean it's understandable if people in the camps truly had extreme thoughts that could threat people's life and the society should be restrained. Why hide? Why hide?! The least part I like about China my home country is how sometimes the government doesn't want to show all facts. No perfect government in the world why hide?!

    • They're hiding evil things.

  • There are more people in US prisons than there are Uighurs in China, where's the human rights out cry? America overthrew China in 1911, killed millions of Chinese, raped, looted, and pillaged. You think those Buddha statues in your museums were just gift from the locals? Where's the human rights out cry? White colonists slaughter the Native Americans, stole their land, got rich of the forced labor of African slaves, built weapons of mass destruction and waged war with the rest of the world. Where's the human rights out cry? Biden voted for wars in Iraq, Afghanistan, Libya, Syria, Ukraine and others, killed millions more, where's his human rights out cry, boycotts and sanctions on US human rights record?

  • Fake news

  • France dont care about Muslims - this is a way to fight Chinese rise in the world. Pathetic!

  • Time will tell the truth when Xingjiang‘s Uygur people getting richer and richer.

  • fake news

    • @Catholon el Bridget I don't know why you're talking about him. The genocide is still real and your comment is still stupid.

    • @Stare Kotlety I am not talking anout Amnesty Int, am talking about Adrian Zenz

    • @Catholon el Bridget Amnesty international is not white supremecist or US funded, you're just making stuff up now.

    • @Stare Kotlety Who are tied to where and who? The US and its militaristic Agenda. I was convinced of this Genocide until I found out its head researcher is a White Supremacist.

    • No, it's real, very well documented by human rights organizations.

  • @